Tutti Frutti Recipe: How to Make Candied Raw Papaya at Home
Homemade Tutti Frutti
Homemade Tutti Frutti is raw papaya cubes candied in sugar syrup, coloured and rested overnight. It is easy, forgiving and wonderfully cheerful, with a soft bite and a clean sweetness that no packet can match.
History and Origin of Tutti Frutti
Tutti frutti is an Italian phrase meaning all fruits. In its original Western form, it describes a mixture of fruits preserved in brandy or another spirit and matured over several months.
The Indian version is a humbler and far quicker cousin. Raw papaya, a fruit the Portuguese brought to India in the 16th century, is candied in sugar syrup and tinted in bright colours, becoming a thrifty stand in for costly candied fruit in bakeries and home kitchens.
Candying is one of the oldest ways to keep fruit, with sugar doing the work of a preservative. That is why Tutti Frutti has long been a faithful companion of Christmas baking.
Western Tutti Frutti vs Indian Tutti Frutti
- Western (European and American) version: A fruit mixture preserved in brandy or another alcohol and prepared over several months.
- Indian version: Candied and coloured raw papaya, used in cookies, fruit cakes, buns, bread loaves, ice creams and puddings. It even turns up as a filling in meetha paan, along with gulkand (candied rose petals).
My Nostalgia and Memory
I have always loved Tutti Frutti, whether it hid in bread loaves, coconut buns, Tutti Frutti ice cream, my all time rich fruit cake or a simple batch of cookies. For the longest time I believed they were candied cherries.
Then my dad told me they were raw papayas, candied and coloured. As a kid, it was a big disappointment for me, but the taste of those candied papayas outlasted the heartbreak, and so did my love for bakery items.
It all began when I was hunting for good quality vanilla essence and mentioned it to my sister in law, who has vanilla growing on her farm. She suggested making vanilla essence at home, and while searching the internet for how, I stumbled upon a video on how to make Tutti Frutti.
The idea of making it from scratch had never occurred to me. The recipe looked easy, and that very day my husband bought a big raw papaya, a coincidence if ever there was one.
Without a second thought, the very next day I made those colourful candied raw papayas, the so called Tutti Frutti. Alongside, I made a batch of candied peels with fresh orange peels too.
That Christmas, my fruit cake turned extra special with my favourite homemade Tutti Frutti and candied orange peels. Why spend money on these goodies when they can be made at home, with no preservatives and the sweetness set to your preference? Half a papaya gave me almost 500 to 750 g, about 3 cups, of colourful Tutti Frutti.
Once they were ready, it was hard not to marvel at them, so colourful and beautiful. I even gobbled up a handful as a snack, a sweet indulgence to reward my cooking endeavour.
Even on my very first attempt, I got the texture perfect. I was so impressed that I started on my candied orange peels right away. All homemade goodness, ready for my Christmas goodies, and I have never gone back to store bought Tutti Frutti and candied peels.
Why You Will Love This Homemade Tutti Frutti
- No preservatives: Just papaya, sugar, vanilla and colour, with nothing you cannot pronounce.
- Sweetness your way: You control the sugar, so it suits your cake, your cookies or your family.
- Budget friendly: Half a raw papaya gives about 3 cups of Tutti Frutti.
- Perfect texture, even first time: Slow cooking until the syrup is absorbed gives dry, glossy, non sticky cubes.
- Make ahead friendly: Prepare it well before Christmas baking and keep it ready.
Recipe Overview
- Cuisine: Indian Bakery Style
- Recipe Type: Candied Fruits, Baking Ingredient, Christmas Recipe
- Yields: 3 cups (about 500 to 750 g)
- Servings: About 20 portions of 2 tbsp
- Difficulty: Medium
- Author: SM @ Essence of Life - Food
Time Estimate
- Preparation Time: 15 to 20 minutes
- Cooking Time: 30 to 45 minutes
- Soaking Time: 12 to 15 hours, or overnight
- Total Time: About 13 to 16 hours
How to Make Tutti Frutti at Home: Step by Step Details
Ingredient List
To Cook the Raw Papayas:
- 3 cups Raw Papaya (firm, peeled, seeds removed, cut into small cubes)
- As required Water
For the Candied Raw Papaya (Tutti Frutti):
- 2 cups Sugar
- 1½ to 2 cups Water
- 1 tsp Vanilla Essence
- A few drops Red Edible Food Colour
- A few drops Orange Edible Food Colour
- A few drops Green Edible Food Colour
Method: Detailed Cooking Instructions
Step 1: Prepare the Raw Papaya
- Make small incisions on the raw papaya. The milky sap will start to ooze out.
- Leave it aside for a few minutes, then wash it under running water until all the milky sap is removed.
- Peel off the skin, cut the raw papaya into halves and remove the seeds along with the white part.
- Chop it into small cubes and keep aside. I used about 3 cups of raw papaya.
Pro Tip: Use firm raw papaya for this recipe, and wash away every trace of the milky sap.
Step 2: Half Cook the Raw Papaya
- Boil enough water in a pan. Once it starts to boil, add the chopped raw papaya and cook on a medium low flame for about 3 to 5 minutes.
- The raw papaya should turn translucent and be only half cooked.
- Drain the half cooked papaya in a colander and keep aside.
Pro Tip: Only half cook the papaya here. It finishes cooking in the syrup, and overcooked cubes turn mushy.
Step 3: Candy the Papaya in Sugar Syrup
- Meanwhile, boil 2 cups of sugar with 1½ to 2 cups of water in a pan, on a medium low flame.
- Once the sugar has completely dissolved and the syrup reaches one string consistency, add the half cooked papaya cubes.
- Cook on a medium low flame for about 12 to 15 minutes, until the papaya is cooked and has absorbed most of the syrup. The mixture will start to thicken slightly at this stage.
- I cooked until the sugar syrup was completely absorbed by the papaya.
- Add 1 tsp of vanilla essence, give a quick stir and switch off the flame.
Pro Tip: The consistency of the syrup and the cooking time decide the final texture. Slow cook with care, and make sure the syrup does not crystallise.
Step 4: Divide and Colour the Candied Papaya
- Divide the candied papaya into 3 portions and add each portion to a separate bowl.
- Add a few drops of red food colour to one bowl, orange to another and green to the remaining bowl.
- Mix well, so that each piece is equally coloured.
Pro Tip: Use good quality edible food colours. I used red, orange and green, but the choice of colours is entirely yours.
Step 5: Rest Overnight
Step 6: Store and Use
- Store the Tutti Frutti in clean airtight containers, individually or combined together.
- For longer shelf life, store it in the refrigerator.
- Use it in cookies, fruit cakes, buns, bread loaves, ice creams and puddings.
Pro Tip: Always use a clean, dry container and a dry spoon, so your Tutti Frutti stays fresh for longer.
Pro Tips and Notes
- Choose firm raw papaya: It holds its shape through boiling and candying. Soft or ripe fruit collapses into mush.
- Syrup and timing decide the texture: I slow cooked with care until all the syrup was completely absorbed by the papaya cubes.
- Prevent crystallisation: Keep the flame medium low and do not let the syrup crystallise during the process.
- Do not overcook: The papaya should never turn mushy.
- Measurements that worked for me: The quantity of sugar and water in this recipe was perfect for the method I followed.
- Rescue moist Tutti Frutti: Leave it on a paper towel until the excess moisture is absorbed.
- Colours are your choice: I used red, orange and green. Always use good quality edible colours.
Serving Suggestions
Fold your homemade Tutti Frutti into Christmas fruit cakes, bread loaves, coconut buns, cookies, puddings and homemade ice cream. A spoonful also makes a pretty and sweet filling for meetha paan, along with gulkand.
For cakes, toss the cubes in a spoonful of flour from your recipe before folding them in, so they stay evenly spread instead of sinking to the bottom.
Storage Suggestions
- Refrigeration: Keep in a clean, dry, airtight container in the refrigerator for longer shelf life. It generally keeps well for 1 to 2 months.
- Freezing and Thawing: Sugar rich candied fruit freezes well. Freeze in a sealed container or freezer bag for up to 6 months, then thaw in the refrigerator or at room temperature before using.
- Reheating: Not needed. Use the Tutti Frutti as it is in your bakes and desserts.
Recipes with Tutti Frutti







FAQ
What is Tutti Frutti made of in India?
Indian Tutti Frutti is made from raw papaya cubes, candied in sugar syrup and coloured with edible food colours.
Why should the raw papaya only be half cooked first?
The papaya finishes cooking in the sugar syrup. Cooking it fully beforehand turns the cubes mushy.
How do I stop the sugar syrup from crystallising?
Cook on a medium low flame, let the sugar dissolve completely and avoid overcooking the syrup.
Can I use ripe papaya to make Tutti Frutti?
No. Use firm raw papaya, which holds its shape through boiling and candying.
How much Tutti Frutti does half a raw papaya make?
Half a papaya gave me almost 500 to 750 g, about 3 cups, of homemade Tutti Frutti.
How long should Tutti Frutti rest after colouring?
Rest it for 12 to 15 hours, or overnight, so the papaya absorbs the sweetness and colour.
Is homemade Tutti Frutti vegan, vegetarian and gluten free?
As written, this recipe uses only papaya, sugar, vanilla essence and food colour, so it is vegetarian, vegan and gluten free.
Where can I use homemade Tutti Frutti?
Use it in cookies, fruit cakes, buns, bread loaves, ice creams and puddings.
Recipes You Might Like From My Blog
- How to Soak Dry Fruits for Christmas Cake: The yearlong ritual that gives my fruit cake its depth.
- Christmas Fruit Cake Recipes: Rich, light and pound cake versions, ready for your Tutti Frutti.
- Christmas, New Year and Easter Recipes: Cakes, cookies and festive bakes for the whole season.
A Little Jar of Christmas Colour
Some sweetness is worth making from scratch. A humble raw papaya, a pan of syrup and a night of patience turn into little jewels of red, orange and green, waiting for the first slice of Christmas cake.
Make a jar, bake something golden with it, and wander through my Christmas kitchen for the rest of the season's treasures.
0 Comments